[Shadowfox5613]

I would give this a 3/10 the art is crap seriously half the pannels have nothing in them and most of the art looks like it was copy and pasted using photo shop, i could do a better job with ms paint!... ex this here... and the story line is crap to the characters all have no personality you cant get attached to any of them they are here there and all over the place with the story 5 panels here 5 panels there then some how they are all somewere else with no explaination. Dont say i need ot read further in because i read to volume 4 it was a fast read... very few words and very simple pictures...

so reasons for the 3/10
1 lazy artist with obvious use of some kind of photo shop type program
2 poorly written storyline
3 flat characters


i am just kinda mad that this is rated so high right now, oh well, for those of you who like this simple stuff rant and rave at me all you like about how huge of an idiot i am being but i would love to hear your reasons why it should be rated higher or lower...


-13

[Levian]

Well, I like this manhwa cuz of the characters, especially the main one, and at least this story didn't have any crappy ending like the others manhwa i read before (shoujo). At least, (for me) it's the only manhwa I've read that got a happy ending.

Note: Are you mad cuz Yureka didn't make top 10 but this manhwa made it? (this's just a conclusion cuz I saw you several times on Yureka. (if I didn't mistake you with someone else)

[Mizuchan]

Originally Posted by Shadowfox5613

2 poorly written storyline

i totaly agree on this cus some pages don't even have writing on them

[xcherry6001]

wow.
if u hate this manhwa so much, why did u read all the way up to vol. 4? just so you could "rant" on how much u hate it?
are u just jealous that the crappy manga/manhwa u like aren't rated as high as this one because clearly this manhwa has a good storyline and characters or else it wouldn't be rated/viewed by this many people.

[kuletchuchi]

Okay. That is a rant.

First of all, You we're ranting about the scanlator and the Author of I accept you right?

Originally Posted by Shadowfox5613

most of the art looks like it was copy and pasted using photo shop, i could do a better job with ms paint!... ex this here

First your ranting about the Scanlator. You said MOST of the ART looks like it was copy and pasted using photoshop. Thats why you said, the Art isn't good. Your actually saying the Art isn't good also because of the Scanlator who posted the manga's here. Okay, You said, You can do a better job with MS paint.
Then why won't you do that 'better job' of your and upload it here on MangaFox, So that the art would be Better. You said it right? You can do better than this? Then show us. I don't want to be rude. But we are really thankful to the scanlator for Uploading the whole chapter. She did her best just to upload the Whole Manhwa and never dropped this Series. It's 6 volumes. But she never dropped this, She put all her whole effort for this? The thing you say, "Copy and pasted using photo shop" Is cooler than "do a better job w/ Ms Paint"

Second, You say, The Art is crap. Seriously, Most of people here are critic?
The Art is crap? Can you draw better than Kwon Yeul-Hee? I don't get it.
Just because it's on the top 15 or Why it is Rated High, You come to see all the Negative Things
About this Manhwa? Saying "The Art is crap" Is like "I'm looking down on this manhwa" Or should we get to the point? "Kwon Yeul-hee sucks" Isn't it? Am i wrong? From your words, Your actually just asking why is it Rated high and Etc. Calling the Art is crap. What the. Seriously, I never called any Manga/Manhwa
a Crap, Especially their art, Seriously, Wanna ask me why? "cause i can't draw better than them".
Got it?

And the story line? Crap. You really love calling it a 'crap' huh. Then, I think your in a Higher Position.
You might be Better than Kwon Yeul-hee's. Calling her Manhwa a crap, Is 'looking down' right?
Then i think Your better than her. Isnt it? In my opinion, I love the story line and the Characters.
So If it's your opinion then it is.

What do you mean, "Lazy artist w/ obvious use of some kind of photo shop program"?
You mean Anonumia? Seriously, If your a Manhwaga/Mangaka you use your HAND
to DRAW a Manhwa/Manga you don't use a Photoshop for that. So Do you mean
It's anonumia? Lazy you say, Does a lazy person can Upload All the Chapters of IAY here in MangaFox
if She is LAZY? Your rude. So i'm rude to you as well. Saying 'Crap' ! 'Crap' ! What a critic.

Poorly written storyline? Then it's for you. Because for me. I find the storyline cool.

Flat characters? I dont find them flat characters? Because if it is. It's just a typical shojo manga
Guy loves Girl, Girl starting to like guy, Start date, Something happens, Break-up, Get back again, Then Finished. It's usually like that right? I don't see them FLAT characters like what you say.

So that just my opinion. Seriously *sigh*

[kuletchuchi]

Originally Posted by xcherry6001

wow.
if u hate this manhwa so much, why did u read all the way up to vol. 4? just so you could "rant" on how much u hate it?
are u just jealous that the crappy manga/manhwa u like aren't rated as high as this one because clearly this manhwa has a good storyline and characters or else it wouldn't be rated/viewed by this many people.

It's so funny, You know, Seriously, I've seen lots of mangafox members here in MF.
That actually, their first post is always at I accept you, and it's so funny because their first post is all about defending it like what happened before. So im somehow happy. Wahaha.

[newtale]

yup .. this manhwa just realy sucked .... Its art was just disgusting ... the storyline was ok .... Just for some timepass .. But the art was really incorigible ... I mean i wasnt able to even differentiate between the characters ...

[arturo]

Alright, I am the type to get emotional really easily when reading manhwa/manga, but I felt nearly nothing when reading this. I did think at one point that it was pretty interesting with the whole Ha-eun thing and her secret but that turned out pretty flat. It's too bad because, even though I hated her for the most part, Ha-eun was an interesting character and had potential. I also feel like this manhwa could have been better if more time was taken to go deeper into some of the issues and relationships, but oh well. On the bright side I don't really feel like I wasted time reading this since it was relatively short and I had nothing else to do at the time.

[HumiGad]

this won't be on the top 10 before if this manga is not that good..

i don't find this good.. i don't find this bad either..
it's average..

[Yuka Misaki]

I cut your words a bit shorter.

Originally Posted by Shadowfox5613

most of the art looks like it was copy and pasted using photo shop, i could do a better job with ms paint!... so reasons for the 3/10
-> lazy artist with obvious use of some kind of photo shop type program
i am just kinda mad that this is rated so high right now

1) If you are really that confident of doing a better job just using ms paint, then prove it.
2) Are you 100% sure that the artist is using "some kind of photoshop type of program"?
3)Everyone really has a different perspective among things just like you. At the same time people also have different likings just like you. You shouldn't get mad of why it is rated high, just think of your own perspective towards it and that should be enough.