MangaFox's Online Community

yukilove21 · 11-03-2009, 03:16 AM

hi X3 i was just reading chapter 34 again and then a thought hit me. does this kwms love triangle reminds of the famous/imfamous love triangel of bella-edward-jacob of twilight, think about it, bella-misaki, edward-usui, jacob-shintani. am i the only one who see's this, misaki and usui's love is sort of forbindin i geuss to many obsticals, bella-edward forbindin love with vamps. and humans. misaki-shintani good friends when they were little good friends now but one falls in love with the other(shintani) when the other(misaki) love someone else(usui), bella-jacob good friends when little, good friends still one falls in love with the other(jacob) the other(bella) is in love with someone else(edward), then there is usui-shintani rivals over the girl(misaki) they both care about and love possibly becoming friends.
edward-jacob rivals not only in love it go's farther than that... possible that they become ftiends(i forgot i haven't read breacking dawn for a while)

i must not be the only one to c this...

p.s; u all just lost the game(which u are ALL playing now rules are that if u c,hear, or think about the games u lose it u can lose every 30 min. and u can never win u can only lose X3 enjoy playing.) XD

Lovey-Dovey Candy · 11-03-2009, 07:53 AM

Yeah, but Bella isn't like Misaki. :P

ryuuzauchi · 11-03-2009, 08:10 AM

there are many mangas and movies and tv dramas out there that have similar triangles...=.=

NO!! of course not!! Definitely NOT!!(such strong opposition is caused only by personal distaste of a certain novel series, (but favorites the movie, so far)
Usui's waaayyyy better than Edward, and Misa's much more independent and mature and explosive than Bella, and HInata(shintani) is well, pathetic in a good way, but still pathetic(=.=)

dizzypineapple78 · 11-03-2009, 06:32 PM

No. Just no.

Many anime and manga have this exact triangle, regardless of the genre or author.

Bella is an emotional weakling who has no will other than to be with Edward. Misaki, on the other hand, isn't even willing to believe that she cares for Usui. She's strong and opinionated, and for the most part refuses to bow down to men.

Usui is more of a lover to Misaki than Edward is. He's a little rude sometimes (but hey, he's human-apparently), but he's not nearly as controlling and selfish as Edward.

Think about your conclusions.

michymoo · 11-03-2009, 10:32 PM

No.
Im sorry, but no.
Most romances have love triangles, wheres the fun in romances if theres no rivalary?
I used to think Twilight was okay, i read the books before the films, and i am goign to watch the films and compare, but now with all the stupid fangirls going "kyaaa!" everytime they hear about Edward Cullen, i have started to hate twilight with a real passion.
Also, Ayuzawa Misaki is nothing like Bella.. Bella is a stupid, dull, boring girl who just got lucky and had a vamp fall for her.
Shintani is nothing like that b**tard Jacob, because Shintani accepts Misaki likes Usui, but he doesn't go off kissing her, does he? Plus Shintani is cute and lovable unlike Jake.
Okay, i'll admit Usui is a bit like Edward, but only the quiet, perfect side, Usui barely ever loses his cool, (unlike Edward, the protective, stupid, idiot) and doesn't go creeping Misaki up in the middle of the night and perving on her. Even though some of his speaches are pervy, but i guess that gives him character.
I've read a lot of mangas, and in all most all of the mangas, there is a thread about twilight saying it is similar because of the love triangle... Deal with it, most shoujos/shounens/romances have it.
And if i see another twilight related thread... i will SCREAM!!

i3shoppers · 11-03-2009, 10:59 PM

to be honest.. i thought of that too

seX_pisToL · 11-03-2009, 11:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by michymoo

No.
Im sorry, but no.
Most romances have love triangles, wheres the fun in romances if theres no rivalary?
I used to think Twilight was okay, i read the books before the films, and i am goign to watch the films and compare, but now with all the stupid fangirls going "kyaaa!" everytime they hear about Edward Cullen, i have started to hate twilight with a real passion.
Also, Ayuzawa Misaki is nothing like Bella.. Bella is a stupid, dull, boring girl who just got lucky and had a vamp fall for her.
Shintani is nothing like that b**tard Jacob, because Shintani accepts Misaki likes Usui, but he doesn't go off kissing her, does he? Plus Shintani is cute and lovable unlike Jake.
Okay, i'll admit Usui is a bit like Edward, but only the quiet, perfect side, Usui barely ever loses his cool, (unlike Edward, the protective, stupid, idiot) and doesn't go creeping Misaki up in the middle of the night and perving on her. Even though some of his speaches are pervy, but i guess that gives him character.
I've read a lot of mangas, and in all most all of the mangas, there is a thread about twilight saying it is similar because of the love triangle... Deal with it, most shoujos/shounens/romances have it.
And if i see another twilight related thread... i will SCREAM!!

AMEN!

but

Twilight??? that's an odd comparison...never came across my mind....lol....

boo-bop · 11-04-2009, 01:09 AM

don;t even go there i am soooo ANTI-twilight!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!

yuukuzuri_Chan · 11-04-2009, 01:46 AM

i dont really get the Twilight craze. it's just another book/movie for me. yeah sure the guys in there are yummy and definitely drool worth, but that's about it. just plain eye candy.
as the others said, love triangles such as this common in most stories/shoujo. romance is a part of life, thats why people love it. and Misaki is much smarter than Bella to go into total decline just because of a guy and trying to forget that certain someone by totally going into rebound with one of your best friends. i find her irritating actually.
Misaki may be a little tactless when it comes to boys, but at least she can still do her job right and communicate with other people. she's more professional. ~~even if she does vent her anger by releasing her demon aura.~~XD at least shes honest bout her feelings. ~~well some of them~~ XD
i've got nothing against Twilight, i do watch the movies and read it's books, its just my opinion.

yukilove21 · 11-04-2009, 02:44 AM

well the lovetirangel is not the charaters in anyway!!!

11-03-2009, 03:16 AM	#1
yukilove21 usaki(misakiXusui<3) Join Date: May 2009 Location: seika high<3 Posts: 578	the misaki-usui-shintani love triangel reminds me of... hi X3 i was just reading chapter 34 again and then a thought hit me. does this kwms love triangle reminds of the famous/imfamous love triangel of bella-edward-jacob of twilight, think about it, bella-misaki, edward-usui, jacob-shintani. am i the only one who see's this, misaki and usui's love is sort of forbindin i geuss to many obsticals, bella-edward forbindin love with vamps. and humans. misaki-shintani good friends when they were little good friends now but one falls in love with the other(shintani) when the other(misaki) love someone else(usui), bella-jacob good friends when little, good friends still one falls in love with the other(jacob) the other(bella) is in love with someone else(edward), then there is usui-shintani rivals over the girl(misaki) they both care about and love possibly becoming friends. edward-jacob rivals not only in love it go's farther than that... possible that they become ftiends(i forgot i haven't read breacking dawn for a while) i must not be the only one to c this... p.s; u all just lost the game(which u are ALL playing now rules are that if u c,hear, or think about the games u lose it u can lose every 30 min. and u can never win u can only lose X3 enjoy playing.) XD __________________ narusasu FTW! usaki FTW! my top shojo and shonen top shojo kaichou wa maid sama, skip beat top shonen bleach, Naruto and loveless, kuroshitsuji "And today, you are deprived of your future by me. That's all".-kuroshitsuji Last edited by yukilove21; 11-03-2009 at 03:19 AM.

11-03-2009, 07:53 AM	#2
Lovey-Dovey Candy Senior Member Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Somewhere... Posts: 108	Yeah, but Bella isn't like Misaki. :P __________________ "Dysfunctional yet sweet~"

11-03-2009, 08:10 AM	#3
ryuuzauchi Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2008 Posts: 151	there are many mangas and movies and tv dramas out there that have similar triangles...=.= NO!! of course not!! Definitely NOT!!(such strong opposition is caused only by personal distaste of a certain novel series, (but favorites the movie, so far) Usui's waaayyyy better than Edward, and Misa's much more independent and mature and explosive than Bella, and HInata(shintani) is well, pathetic in a good way, but still pathetic(=.=) __________________

11-03-2009, 06:32 PM	#4
dizzypineapple78 Member Join Date: May 2009 Location: in your attic Posts: 33	No. Just no. Many anime and manga have this exact triangle, regardless of the genre or author. Bella is an emotional weakling who has no will other than to be with Edward. Misaki, on the other hand, isn't even willing to believe that she cares for Usui. She's strong and opinionated, and for the most part refuses to bow down to men. Usui is more of a lover to Misaki than Edward is. He's a little rude sometimes (but hey, he's human-apparently), but he's not nearly as controlling and selfish as Edward. Think about your conclusions. __________________ admit impediments.

11-03-2009, 10:59 PM	#6
i3shoppers Junior Member Join Date: Aug 2009 Posts: 15	to be honest.. i thought of that too __________________ Kimi Wa Pet The Wallflower Hana Kimi Paradise Kiss

11-03-2009, 10:32 PM	#5
michymoo Junior Member Join Date: Oct 2009 Posts: 5	No. Im sorry, but no. Most romances have love triangles, wheres the fun in romances if theres no rivalary? I used to think Twilight was okay, i read the books before the films, and i am goign to watch the films and compare, but now with all the stupid fangirls going "kyaaa!" everytime they hear about Edward Cullen, i have started to hate twilight with a real passion. Also, Ayuzawa Misaki is nothing like Bella.. Bella is a stupid, dull, boring girl who just got lucky and had a vamp fall for her. Shintani is nothing like that b**tard Jacob, because Shintani accepts Misaki likes Usui, but he doesn't go off kissing her, does he? Plus Shintani is cute and lovable unlike Jake. Okay, i'll admit Usui is a bit like Edward, but only the quiet, perfect side, Usui barely ever loses his cool, (unlike Edward, the protective, stupid, idiot) and doesn't go creeping Misaki up in the middle of the night and perving on her. Even though some of his speaches are pervy, but i guess that gives him character. I've read a lot of mangas, and in all most all of the mangas, there is a thread about twilight saying it is similar because of the love triangle... Deal with it, most shoujos/shounens/romances have it. And if i see another twilight related thread... i will SCREAM!!

11-04-2009, 01:09 AM	#8
boo-bop ☻♥♫ i love shojo manga☻♥♫ Join Date: Jan 2009 Location: Ƹ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒbubble world♥♫♪ Posts: 289	don;t even go there i am soooo ANTI-twilight!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!! __________________ My Fav Mangas (loves Shojo) Lovely Complex/OtaniXRisa Kaichou wa maid-sama/UsuiXMisaki Charming Junkie Moe Kare!!/ArataXHikaru Koukou Debut Hana Yori Dango/TsukushiXDomyoji Hana Kimi Dengeki Daisy/KurosakiXTeru Kyou, koi wo Hajimemasu Kimi ni Todoke/KazehayaXSawako Hadashi de bara wo Fume Shinobi Life/KagetoraXBeni devil and her love song and Hwang Mi Ri's manhwa's!!!!!!

11-04-2009, 01:46 AM	#9
yuukuzuri_Chan ~chocolate is comfort~ Join Date: May 2009 Location: ~clouds in the sky~ Posts: 288	i dont really get the Twilight craze. it's just another book/movie for me. yeah sure the guys in there are yummy and definitely drool worth, but that's about it. just plain eye candy. as the others said, love triangles such as this common in most stories/shoujo. romance is a part of life, thats why people love it. and Misaki is much smarter than Bella to go into total decline just because of a guy and trying to forget that certain someone by totally going into rebound with one of your best friends. i find her irritating actually. Misaki may be a little tactless when it comes to boys, but at least she can still do her job right and communicate with other people. she's more professional. ~~even if she does vent her anger by releasing her demon aura.~~XD at least shes honest bout her feelings. ~~well some of them~~ XD i've got nothing against Twilight, i do watch the movies and read it's books, its just my opinion. __________________ ~HOLD MY HAND~ ~TOUCH MY HEART~

11-04-2009, 02:44 AM	#10
yukilove21 usaki(misakiXusui<3) Join Date: May 2009 Location: seika high<3 Posts: 578	well the lovetirangel is not the charaters in anyway!!! __________________ narusasu FTW! usaki FTW! my top shojo and shonen top shojo kaichou wa maid sama, skip beat top shonen bleach, Naruto and loveless, kuroshitsuji "And today, you are deprived of your future by me. That's all".-kuroshitsuji

MangaFox's Online Community

Urban Sidewalk Incinerator